Dubrovnik had the wow factor. Makarska suited us better overall though.
Dubrovnik Old Town at dusk
This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.
We spent two consecutive summer holidays in Croatia: first seven nights at Sun Gardens Dubrovnik, around 20 minutes outside Dubrovnik, and then ten nights at the Aminess Khalani Hotel in Makarska the following summer.
They were both very good holidays, but they showed us two quite different versions of Croatia.
If we could combine the best bits, the answer would actually be fairly simple: Dubrovnik on the doorstep, but with the beaches, restaurants and seafront walkability we had in Makarska.
If we found that combination, we’d probably choose Dubrovnik.
Because Dubrovnik itself is stunning.
But the two holidays also helped shape our wider view of Croatia. It has a coastline that feels quite distinctive from much of the Mediterranean. The pebble beaches help give the water an extraordinary clarity and depth of colour, and at times Croatia feels almost like a fusion of Greece and Italy — something you notice in the architecture, the food and the general atmosphere.
If you’ve travelled around the Mediterranean a lot and occasionally feel that some of the mainstream resorts are beginning to merge into one another, Croatia is just a bit different. There is a touch of beauty, class and distinction to it that has made it one of our favourite places for a coastal holiday in Europe.

Dubrovnik had the bigger wow factor
Dubrovnik Old Town was one of the highlights of either trip.
Its historic significance isn’t just tourist-board hyperbole: the Old City is a UNESCO World Heritage Site, with Gothic, Renaissance and Baroque buildings within its historic fabric.
What appealed to us, though, was the contrast within it.
The main streets can be polished, smart and busy, but wander up the steps and into the narrower streets and it changes. There are worn stone walls, tiny alleys, washing overhead and corners that feel much more lived-in.
Dubrovnik also had plenty of energy. The Old Town was bustling, with a huge choice of restaurants, cafés and bars packed into and around the streets. The frustration for us was being based away from all of that at Sun Gardens — once we were in Dubrovnik, there was no shortage of places to wander, eat, drink or simply soak up the atmosphere.

It manages to be impressive without feeling completely like a museum.
We only did part of the city walls rather than the full circuit, but even that was excellent. The rooftop and sea views are spectacular, although for us the busy, atmospheric streets inside the Old Town — restaurants, cafés, bars and all — were probably even more memorable than looking down on it.
That is something Makarska can’t quite match.
Makarska is very attractive. Dubrovnik feels special.
Our decision not to repeat exactly the same holiday the following summer wasn’t really because of Dubrovnik. It was more about how we like to spend a holiday.
Sun Gardens was excellent — but it depends what you want from a resort

Sun Gardens Dubrovnik is an impressive resort.
The grounds were immaculate, the coastal setting superb and there was plenty to do. We particularly liked the sea: swimming, snorkelling and jumping into the water from the piers became a big part of the holiday, and we generally preferred that to spending all day around the pools.
There was also a good choice of restaurants on site.
So describing Sun Gardens simply as “too isolated” would be unfair.
For somebody who wants to arrive at a high-quality resort, relax by the pool or sea and not feel any particular need to go anywhere else, its location could actually be a strength. Plenty of travellers clearly like exactly that.
We’re just not really flop-and-drop holidaymakers.
We like going out, wandering around, trying different restaurants and seeing what is nearby. From Sun Gardens, doing that generally meant getting a taxi. It was easy enough, but there wasn’t a town or seafront immediately outside where we could simply decide to go for a walk after dinner.
That distinction matters. The resort wasn’t short of things to do or places to eat. We just like exploring beyond the resort as well.
And that became one of the things we deliberately looked for the following summer.
We did get out plenty while staying there. The Elafiti islands were one of our favourite days, visiting Lopud, Šipan and Koločep.

Šipan was probably the prettiest for us, particularly around Suđurađ, with exceptionally clear water and a small harbour setting that felt very Croatian.
Koločep felt a little more mainstream but was still attractive, while Lopud was probably the most unusual of the three, with its characterful waterfront and sandy beach.

We also went to Zaton, which offered something completely different from Dubrovnik. It was a quiet place to wander, swim and have a drink, and we stayed for dinner at Konoba Kasar in Zaton Veliki.
That’s one I would mention to a friend. It sits right by the water and the setting was a big part of the appeal.

Makarska gave us more on our doorstep

That first holiday helped explain why Makarska suited us so well the following year.
We stayed at the Aminess Khalani Hotel, which gave us the sort of resort-style hotel we wanted while also letting us walk straight out into the surrounding area.
One of its biggest advantages was the seafront promenade.
From the hotel area you could follow the coast all the way towards Makarska town, passing beaches, restaurants, bars and cafés as you went. The centre is roughly a 20-minute coastal walk away, and the promenade itself became part of the holiday rather than simply a route from A to B.

That was a real draw for us.
You could spend the day around the hotel or beach, then later just walk out and see where you ended up. There was no need to make a plan every time we wanted a change of scenery.
Makarska itself felt lively, stylish and busy in quite a happy way.
The setting is superb. There is the Adriatic on one side and the mountains rising dramatically behind the town on the other, with pine-backed pebble beaches running along the coast.
It doesn’t feel like a generic beach resort.
The main drawback for us was peak-summer crowding.
Some of the most central beaches were extremely busy — genuinely packed rather than simply popular.
But having plenty within walking distance helped. Around Plaža Ramova and Cvitačka Beach, we found beaches that we preferred: more attractive, more varied and generally calmer.

That choice became one of Makarska’s biggest strengths.
Brela, Jelsa and exploring beyond Makarska
We also really liked Brela.
It felt less built-up than Makarska and perhaps slightly prettier, with clear water, pale pebble beaches, pine trees and the mountains behind.
The snorkelling was particularly memorable. We saw shoals of fish very close to shore, and the water had the same extraordinary colour and clarity that we associate with this part of Croatia.
Brela is also home to Kamen Brela — the Rock of Brela, the small pine-covered rock just offshore that has become one of the town’s best-known symbols.

For us, Brela was somewhere we were very pleased to visit, although we’d probably still choose Makarska as the base for a longer stay because of the greater choice of restaurants and evening atmosphere.
We also did a three-island speedboat trip from Makarska, including a stop at Jelsa on Hvar.
Jelsa was one of the real highlights of the holiday and, genuinely, one of the prettiest places I’ve ever been.
It seemed to contain so much of what we had started to associate with Croatia in one small place: pale stone buildings, little squares and lanes, old churches, shuttered houses and a harbourfront full of boats.
Architecturally, it has that distinctive Dalmatian mixture of old stone buildings with Gothic, Renaissance and Baroque influences. Yet it doesn’t feel like somewhere preserved purely for visitors. It still feels like a proper little town.

We were only there as part of the boat trip, but it left a much bigger impression than the amount of time we spent there would suggest.
It is exactly the sort of place that reinforces why Croatia feels a little different from much of the Mediterranean.
Which would we choose?
The more we’ve thought about it, the less we see this as a simple Dubrovnik-versus-Makarska contest.
Dubrovnik is the more impressive destination.
If somebody who had never visited Croatia asked which of the two gave us the bigger wow factor, we’d say Dubrovnik.
Makarska gave us the holiday setup that suited us better.
We liked walking out of the hotel and immediately having beaches, restaurants, the promenade and the town available to us.
If your ideal holiday is an excellent resort where you can settle in and hardly leave, Sun Gardens’ relative seclusion might not bother you at all. It may even be part of the attraction.
We aren’t quite wired that way.
We like a good hotel, but we also like stepping outside it and seeing what’s going on.
So if we were choosing between the two holidays exactly as we experienced them, we’d probably lean towards Makarska for a longer family summer break.
But give us a hotel with Makarska’s beach choice and walkability, close to Dubrovnik, and we’d probably choose Dubrovnik.
Perhaps somewhere such as Cavtat might offer some of that combination, but we haven’t stayed there and wouldn’t pretend to know how it compares with Makarska for beaches, restaurants or atmosphere.
What we’re more certain about is Croatia itself.
After two summers there, we don’t think of it as simply another Mediterranean beach destination. The coastline, the water, the islands, the towns and that mixture of Italian and Greek influences give it an identity of its own.
For us, that’s the reason we’re likely to keep going back.
If you’re considering either hotel from our two Croatia holidays, you can check current prices and availability below.
Sun Gardens Dubrovnik — our more self-contained resort near Dubrovnik.
Check prices and availability on Booking.com
Aminess Khalani, Makarska — our hotel with the seafront promenade on its doorstep.
Check prices and availability on Booking.com
Affiliate disclosure: We may receive a commission if you book through these links, at no extra cost to you.

